Google Ads: Automatic Bidding Vs. Manual Bidding
| |

Google Ads: Automatic Bidding vs. Manual Bidding

For many companies, Google Ads is an easy and effective way to promote their products and brand.

Google Ads levels the playing field for smaller companies by enabling them to advertise without laying out large sums of capital.

Recently, Google has gone even further by offering the option of allowing artificial intelligence (AI) to run pay-per-click (PPC) campaigns.

This is a risky gambit for many companies. If you have limited resources and a shrinking advertising budget, you may be hesitant to turn over control of your PPC campaign to an automated process.

In this blog, I’ll review several important considerations related to manual bidding versus automated bidding.

Why Companies Use Pay-Per-Click

More and more people are using the Internet to shop, communicate, and socialize. This shift in where the public spends the majority of its time has made Google—the world’s premiere search engine—an advertising giant.

What You Should Know About Manual Bidding

Manual bidding, as the phrase suggests, is the direct and on-hands management of keyword bids on Google Ads. You make all decisions about your PPC account without AI assistance.

Experience, unique market insight and expertise, and analysis of past keyword performance data can all be used to guide such decision-making. However, it should be noted that this process requires a great deal of time and effort. To get a good return on manual bidding, the people involved in it must be highly competent and have the right level of experience.

This form of bidding may be best if you have a limited budget and a small amount of consumer data. The benefits of manual bidding include:

  • Control: You can be as aggressive as you want to win bids on specific key words and phrases
  • Responsiveness: You can change your keyword bids quickly in response to new competitors and your lowest performers
  • No delays: Manual bidding changes take effect immediately

You should also be aware of the downsides of manual bidding. As your PPC account grows bigger, it will become harder to manage. You may be compelled to hire more people to monitor and manage it, which can eat away at your advertising budget. Manual bidding is also vulnerable to human errors, some of which can be quite costly.

What You Should Know About Automatic Bidding

Automatic bidding is also known as smart bidding. This form of bidding is the best option if you have large PPC accounts, a great deal of historical data, and no experts in manual bidding and no desire to hire any.

If you are a growing company or a well-established one with significant capital reserves, you may be better off letting Google AI take charge of your account.

Here are some of the specific benefits of going down this route:

  • Versatile segmentation: This involves the creation of customized subsections within your broader target audience based on their shared interests and behaviors
  • Efficiency: The AI technology will allow you to manage thousands of keywords and hundreds of ad groups at once
  • Accurate prediction models: The advanced algorithms can give you a sound foundation for decision-making by making accurate predictions about your campaigns
  • Cost-effectiveness: Your team will spend less time on monitoring your Google Ads accounts, which will free them up for more pressing business matters

While automated bidding is a highly effective way to manage your PPC campaign, in almost all cases, you should not start off with it. The smarter move is to go with manual bidding initially, test the waters, and wait until your account has a steady flow of traffic and you have reached a statistically significant number of conversions from which you can make educated decisions.

You should also be aware that any changes you make to Google Ads will take some time to implement if you are using AI. You will need to manually sync if you want the changes to take effect immediately.

If you intend to pursue automated bidding, then there are a few common strategies—which appear as settings on the account—that are worth learning about. They include:

1. Maximize conversions

This sets keyword bids to get the most conversions possible with a given budget. If you set your account to maximize conversions, the AI system will check your daily budget and determine how best to use it. You should be warned that your entire budget can be consumed if you are not careful, which is why you should carve out a stand-alone budget for this type of campaign.

2. Maximize clicks

If you configure your Google Ads campaign with this option, the top priority will be getting ad clicks. The AI system will automatically determine bids based on the likelihood of earning a click or conversion. The system will do so based on the following criteria: device, operating system, demographics, location, and time of day.

It is still possible to set bid limits with this option. However, you should be aware that excessively tight limits will restrict the number of clicks you may get.

There are real differences between manual and automatic bidding on Google Ads. If you have just established a start-up, then you should begin with manual bidding. Over time, you may decide to opt for automatic bidding. But this decision should only be made in light of your PPC budget, your business goals, and the experience and expertise of your workforce.

Pay-Per-Click Lead Generation
Don’t have time to manage your Google Ads, configure landing pages and analytics scripts, or worry about which version of your ad generates the best ROI? That’s OK! Search Engine Pros are here to help! Give us a call at 805-627-3255 or contact us online today.
Get ready to take your Google Ads game to the next level with our comprehensive checklist. Start maximizing your campaign's potential today!


  1. If you don’t know what you’re doing, Google Ads can be tough to use. I like manual bidding because I enjoy hustling to win bids on various keywords and phrases. I’ll keep these tips in mind!

    1. Thanks for sharing your thoughts, Rohan! Manual bidding definitely requires more effort and expertise, but it can also give you more control over your campaigns and potentially lead to better results. It’s great that you enjoy the challenge of bidding for keywords and phrases, but it’s also important to consider using automatic bidding if you don’t have the time or knowledge to constantly monitor and adjust your bids. It’s always good to experiment with both methods and see what works best for your specific goals and budget.

  2. When it comes to bidding I prefer manual, however, automatic is good because it allows you to set your maximum price and you can go on with your day with bidding automatically. I have no idea what google ads are about so it would not be a choice for me. Thanks for the information it was very insightful.

    1. Hi Gail, I’m glad you found the information provided in the blog insightful. While manual bidding can be beneficial for those who want more control over their bidding strategy, automatic bidding can also be useful for those who want to save time and effort. As you mentioned, automatic bidding allows you to set a maximum price, and then the system will bid for you within that limit. This can be particularly helpful for those who are new to Google Ads or do not have the time to constantly monitor and adjust their bids. If you ever decide to explore Google Ads in the future, both manual and automatic bidding options are available, so you can choose what works best for your specific goals and needs.

  3. Years ago, I tried out Google Ads without doing much research before jumping in. I used manual bidding at very low rates. It did not go well for me. My ads got put on the third or fourth page, which most of us know people seldom go beyond the second page. Since my business was always small, it would not have made sense for me to use AI, but looking back, it would have been good to learn more about Google Ads. Google Ads are one of the most effective ways to increase website traffic. I know I most often click on them when searching for items.

    1. Thank you for sharing your experience with Google Ads, Mary. It’s true that using manual bidding can be tricky and requires a good understanding of the bidding process to ensure that your ads are being seen by the right audience at the right time. However, I’m glad to hear that you recognize the value of Google Ads in driving website traffic. It’s definitely worth taking the time to learn more about Google Ads and how they can benefit your business. Automatic bidding can also be a helpful option, as long as you set your maximum price appropriately and regularly monitor your campaigns to ensure that they are performing well. Good luck with your future advertising endeavors!

  4. When it comes to google ads, I am about as clueless as can be. If you don’t know what you are doing, it can be very easy to rack up hundreds of dollars in ad costs. My advice would be to set your budget very low until you understand how it works. Otherwise, you could end up with a thousand dollar charge and no click-throughs to show for it. Be very careful and do your research before beginning a google ad campaign.

    1. That’s a great piece of advice, April. It’s always better to start with a low budget and increase it gradually as you understand how Google Ads work. It can be easy to overspend if you don’t have a clear understanding of the platform and how it works. Doing proper research and experimenting with different bidding strategies can help you optimize your campaigns and get the most out of your ad spend.

  5. Bernadette says:

    At the start of my business, I was wondering what platform should I opt to use. During then, I believe Google has the widest target market, as it is indeed reliable. It was then overwhelming to utilize Google; based on my impression, large companies only apply to such advertising services! I agree, as a start-up company or a starting one, there is a need for them to utilize manual bidding instead. Such may be a risky thing to do, especially if the benefits of such a campaign are not as effective or if there are other services that are in dire need to be improved within the company itself.

    1. Hey, Bernadette. It’s understandable to feel overwhelmed when starting out with Google Ads, especially if you’re new to advertising or have a small business. Manual bidding can be a good option to start with as it allows you to have more control over your spending and target specific keywords. As your business grows and you become more familiar with the platform, you can consider using automatic bidding or other advanced features. It’s important to carefully consider your advertising goals and budget before jumping into any advertising campaign, and to continue to monitor and adjust your strategy as needed.

  6. I’m really at the point I am debating on which advertiser to choose between Google and Facebook. I would like to do both but the budget doesn’t really call for it. I read over your Facebook marketing post also and it sounds appealing. I just want to make for certain my stuff is in Google though. I know I scroll through Facebook ads like they are nothing sometimes and I seem to pay more attention to the Google ads since they are up front right away. I think you have pointed me in the right direction after checking out both of these. Thank you so much.

    1. Hi Diane, I’m glad you found the article helpful in deciding between Google Ads and Facebook Ads. Both platforms have their advantages and disadvantages, so it’s important to choose the one that suits your business goals and target audience best. Google Ads is great for targeting people who are actively searching for products or services like yours. It has a wider reach and can help increase website traffic, which can lead to more conversions. On the other hand, Facebook Ads is ideal for targeting a specific audience based on their interests, demographics, and behavior. It’s also more cost-effective and can help build brand awareness.

      If you’re looking to generate leads or sales quickly, Google Ads might be the way to go. But if you want to build a loyal following and engage with your audience, Facebook Ads can be a great option. Ultimately, it’s up to you to decide which platform best aligns with your business goals and budget. Good luck with your advertising campaigns!

  7. Thank you highlighting the pros and cons of each form of bidding. Personally, the automatic bidding still makes me nervous and I am very hesitant to use it.
    I know Google has greatly improved its automatic bidding over the last few years, but for now, continuing to use a manual method will be the best for me.
    I had a discussion with someone at a Zoom networking event last week who was using an automatic bidding method in order to “maximize conversions” as you described, but did not have very good luck with it. And top of that, cost them quite a bit of money. I would be interested to hear any additional tips you might have for being successful with using automatic bidding.

    1. I’m glad you found the article helpful, Lindsey! I can understand why automatic bidding makes you nervous, as it can be difficult to relinquish control over the bidding process. However, as you mentioned, Google’s automatic bidding has improved over the years and can be a great option for businesses that are looking to optimize their campaigns for specific goals, such as maximizing conversions.

      If you do decide to try automatic bidding, here are a few tips that might be helpful:

      1. Start small: Begin with a low budget to test the waters and see how automatic bidding performs for your business. Once you have a better understanding of how it works, you can gradually increase your budget.

      2. Set clear goals: Make sure you have a clear idea of what you want to achieve with your campaign and use the appropriate bidding strategy to help you reach those goals. For example, if you want to increase conversions, use the maximize conversions bidding strategy.

      3. Monitor your campaign closely: Keep an eye on your campaign performance and adjust your bidding strategy as necessary. This can help you optimize your campaign and improve its overall effectiveness.

      I hope these tips are helpful. Good luck with your Google Ads campaigns!

  8. Google is at the point where I feel like they are advanced enough for me to believe in their AI system. We just simply dont have the time to sit and try to play the keyword game, plus we just arent that good at it. We will see what happens, but I fully have confidence in Google that their “bots” know what they are doing and are going off previous things that have worked for other companies. Google is probably smarter than us!

    1. Thanks for sharing your thoughts, Drew! While it’s true that Google’s AI systems have improved significantly in recent years, it’s still important to approach automatic bidding with caution. It’s always a good idea to closely monitor your campaigns and adjust your bidding strategy as needed, regardless of whether you’re using manual or automatic bidding. Remember that Google’s algorithms are designed to optimize for specific goals (such as maximizing conversions or clicks), but they may not always align with your specific business objectives. Additionally, it’s important to have a good understanding of your target audience and how to effectively target them with your ads, as this can have a significant impact on the success of your campaign.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *